The Politics of Setting

This post was first published on my old Gifted Phoenix Blog back in November 2014.

Much of it is still relevant – parts are even somewhat prophetic.

 

Tim Dracup's avatarGifted Phoenix

I had been intending never to revisit the difficult topic of setting, secure in the knowledge that I could not improve on my earlier treatment of the pros and cons.

P1010978 Irrelevant picture of Norway by Gifted Phoenix

But recent developments have caused me to reconsider, led me to address the issue from a different perspective.

My previous post attempted an objective and balanced statement of the educational arguments for and against, drawing on the research evidence and taking account of all learners, regardless of their attainment.

This one explores how setting – just one option within the far wider range of so-called ‘ability grouping’ strategies –…

View original post 11,228 more words

One response to “The Politics of Setting”

  1. […] has made setting irrelevant. For a real insight into the politics of setting see Tim Dracup’s incredible blog. Ability groups is rubbish if you are in the bottom […]

    Like

Leave a comment

Eponymous, better known as timdracup.com, contains long-form posts drafted by a real human being. Everything is free to read. I specialise in Dracup family history, British walking trails and literary book reviews. But you’ll also find writing about music, bereavement and much else besides.

Designed with WordPress.

The Needle’s Eye – Margaret Drabble

Having reviewed A.S. Byatt’s ‘The Virgin in the Garden’ last year, I decided to return to the work of her sister, Margaret Drabble. Our only previous encounter involved ‘The Garrick Year’ (1964) which I tackled in the sixth form, during the hot summer of 1976, almost exactly half a century ago. She was born three…

Pembrokeshire Coast Path: St Dogmaels to Abercastle

Having completed the South West Coast Path in September 2025, and even reprised the first section so that Tracy could complete it too, it was time for a new challenge. So, at the end of June 2026, we began the Pembrokeshire Coast Path. It extends 186 miles (299 kilometres) between St Dogmaels, near Cardigan, and…

The King of a Rainy Country – Brigid Brophy

Brigid Antonia Brophy (1929-1995) was born in Ealing, London, to John Brophy, an author and journalist, and Charis, nee Grundy, a teacher. She attended a variety of secondary schools before winning a scholarship to Oxford, where she studied classics. But she was invited to leave without completing her degree, for reasons she preferred to gloss…