The Politics of Selection: Grammar Schools and Disadvantage

Reblogging this post published in November 2014 on my Gifted Phoenix Blog.

Tim Dracup's avatarGifted Phoenix

This post considers how England’s selective schools are addressing socio-economic disadvantage.

Another irrelevant Norwegian vista by Gifted Phoenix Another irrelevant Norwegian vista by Gifted Phoenix

It is intended as an evidence base against which to judge various political statements about the potential value of selective education as an engine of social mobility.

It does not deal with recent research reports about the historical record of grammar schools in this respect. These show that – contrary to received wisdom – selective education has had a very limited impact on social mobility.

Politicians of all parties would do well to acknowledge this, rather than attempting (as some do) to perpetuate the myth in defiance of the evidence.

This post concentrates instead on the current record of these schools, recent efforts to strengthen their capacity to support the Government’s gap closing strategy and prospects for the future.

It encourages advocates of increased selection to consider the wider question of how…

View original post 12,048 more words

Leave a comment

Eponymous, better known as timdracup.com, contains long-form posts drafted by a real human being. Everything is free to read. I specialise in Dracup family history, British walking trails and literary book reviews. But you’ll also find writing about music, bereavement and much else besides.

Designed with WordPress.

Growth of the Soil – Knut Hamsun

Since I’m heading imminently to Norway, it seemed appropriate to read a seminal work by a Norwegian author. This was my second encounter with Hamsun, having completed his early, semi-autobiographical novel ‘Hunger’ (1890) some 20 to 30 years ago. Knut Hamsun (1859-1952) was originally Knud Pederson, born into comparative poverty in central Norway. Knud’s father…

The Needle’s Eye – Margaret Drabble

Having reviewed A.S. Byatt’s ‘The Virgin in the Garden’ last year, I decided to return to the work of her sister, Margaret Drabble. Our only previous encounter involved ‘The Garrick Year’ (1964) which I tackled in the sixth form, during the hot summer of 1976, almost exactly half a century ago. She was born three…

Pembrokeshire Coast Path: St Dogmaels to Abercastle

Having completed the South West Coast Path in September 2025, and even reprised the first section so that Tracy could complete it too, it was time for a new challenge. So, at the end of June 2026, we began the Pembrokeshire Coast Path. It extends 186 miles (299 kilometres) between St Dogmaels, near Cardigan, and…